Skip to primary navigationSkip to main contentSkip to footer
  • 1860 Semoran Blvd. Winter Park, FL
  • (407) 677-8354
  • Toggle Search Menu
  • INVENTORYToggle INVENTORY Menu
    • Loose Stones
    • Engagement Rings
    • Women's Wedding Bands
    • Men's Wedding Bands
    • Women's Fashion Rings
    • Men's Fashion Rings
    • Earrings
    • Pendants & Charms
    • Necklaces
    • Chains
    • Bracelets
    • Pins & Brooches
    • Watches
    • Engraveable Items
    • Children's Jewelry
    • Minerals
  • ESTATE
  • CUSTOM
Monarch Jewelry logo
  • Inventory
    Engagement Rings
    Diamond Engagement RingsDiamond Wedding Sets
    Women's Wedding Bands
    Diamond Wedding BandsGold Wedding BandsDiamond Anniversary Bands
    Men's Wedding Bands
    Diamond Wedding BandsGold Wedding Bands
    Women's Fashion Rings
    Diamond Fashion RingsLab Grown Diamond Fashion RingsColored Stone RingsPearl RingsSilver Rings
    Men's Fashion Rings
    Diamond Fashion RingsColored Stone Rings
    Earrings
    Diamond EarringsLab Grown Diamond EarringsGold EarringsColored Stone EarringsSilver Earrings
    Pendants & Charms
    Diamond PendantsGold Pendants & CharmsColored Stone PendantsPearl PendantsSilver Pendants and Charms
    Necklaces
    Diamond NecklacesLab Grown Diamond NecklacesGold NecklacesColored Stone NecklacesPearl NecklacesChains
    Bracelets
    Diamond BraceletsLab Grown Diamond BraceletsGold BraceletsColored Stone BraceletsPearl BraceletsSilver Bracelets
    Pins & Brooches
    Diamond Pins & BroochesGold Pins & BroochesColored Stone Pins & BroochesPearl Pins & Brooches
    Children's Jewelry
    Minerals

    Explore All Inventory
  • Colored Gemstone Jewelry
    Loose Colored Stones
    Colored Stone Rings
    Colored Stone Earrings
    Colored Stone Pendants
    Colored Stone Necklaces
    Colored Stone Bracelets
    Colored Stone Pins & Brooches

    Explore All Colored Gemstone Jewelry
  • Estate
    • Victorian
    • Art Nouveau
    • Art Deco
    • Retro
    • Contemporary
  • Watches
  • Custom
  • Services
    Financing
    Jewelry Engraving
    Jewelry Repairs
    Sell Your Gold
    Sell Your Silverware
    Sell Your Watch
    Watch Repairs
    Check Repair Status

    Explore All Services
  • Contact
  • Sale
  • About Us
    About Monarch Jewelry
    Meet the Staff
    Blog
    Upcoming Events
    Store Reviews

    Explore All About Us
  • RING BUILDER
  • SERVICES
  • CONTACT
  • Toggle Search Menu
  • Toggle My Account Menu
  • Toggle Shopping Cart Menu
Your Widget Header Text Goes Here This banner image is 1600 x 600 pixels on desktop Monarch Jewelry Winter Park, FL

Sell Your Diamonds in Orlando

Visit our jewelry store to sell your diamonds in Orlando.

free estimate

How To Sell Your Diamonds

We will evaluate your diamonds while you watch and tell you the value of what you have. If you decide to sell, we will write you a check on the spot.

LARGER DIAMONDS
(ABOVE 1/4CT)

We estimate the size and quality of your diamond and make you an offer. For added assurance, before we finalize the transaction we often remove the diamond from the setting to verify the details of the diamond with you.

ESTATE

Your older diamonds have a different value than new modern brilliant cut diamonds. We have the expertise to evaluate those diamonds make recommendations based on each piece.

SMALLER DIAMONDS (BELOW 1/4CT)

We add up all the diamonds in your jewelry and estimate the total weight then our offer includes the added value of those diamonds.

book appointment

Sell Your Diamonds at Monarch Jewelry

There is nothing more precious than a dazzling diamond, but if it’s getting no use or love, why not sell it? The Orlando area trusts in Monarch Jewelry for our competitive pricing and our quality service. We’re more than happy to sit down with you, talk you through the diamond buying process, and allow you to decide if you’re ready to part with your sparkle.

contact us
Monarch Jewelry Winter Park, FL

The Best Price For Your Diamonds

In addition to evaluating each piece for the above criteria, we also have three options open to you. We will discuss with you the one that best suits your needs. These options are:
HIGHEST VALUE: Trade in or Redesign. You will get the highest value for your diamond when you trade it in for another piece of jewelry that may be more fashion forward or that you would enjoy wearing again. By trading in, you get a fresh new look and the benefit of the highest value. For more information, check out our in-house custom design process. (Link to custom design page)
BEST VALUE Consignment. When we evaluate your diamond, we can make a higher offer if you leave it on consignment. If you are not in a rush to receive the cash value of your items, then this might be a better option
GOOD VALUE: Cash. Sometimes you need the cash right away or you just don’t want to mess with it. We will make you a cash offer for your diamonds.

sell your jewelry
Monarch Jewelry Winter Park, FL

TESTIMONIALS

“I inherited from my Mom a complete silverware set for twelve, including serving utensils and even a sugar bowl. All items had been in the back of my closet for many years as our family did not have fancy events. Monarch Jewelry suggested I bring it in to evaluate and when they did, I was pleasantly surprised at the value of what they offered me for it. I am glad not to have to worry about this silver set that I would have had to pass on to my children so they could put it in the back of their closet”

more reviews
Monarch Jewelry Winter Park, FL

Talk With an Expert

You will get the highest value for your diamonds when you trade it in for another piece of jewelry that may be more fashion forward or that you would enjoy wearing again. By trading in, you get a fresh new look and the benefit of the highest value. For more information, check out our in-house custom design process.

When we evaluate your diamond, we can make a higher offer if you leave it on consignment. If you are not in a rush to receive the cash value of your items, then this might be a better option

call us
Monarch Jewelry
Winter Park Store
1860 State Road 436
Winter Park, FL 32792
(407) 677-8354
Store Information
Mon - Fri:10:00am - 6:00pm
Saturday:10:00am - 4:00pm
Sunday:Closed
Ring Builder
  • Introducing RingBuilder by Monarch Jewelry – your gateway to crafting the perfect ring. Design and personalize your dream engagement or fashion ring with ease. Select from a dazzling array of precious metals, gemstones, and settings, all at your fingertips.
Diamond Search
Subscribe

Signup for special offers and discounts.

© 2025 Monarch Jewelry. All Rights Reserved. Website designed, maintained, and hosted by Punchmark. Accessibility Statement.

Learn how we use cookies in our Privacy Policy or manage cookie preferences.